LPG Generator

Dec 29, 2012
148
Hunter 37 Jacksonville
I've toyed with adding a generator. But always insisted that I would only accept a diesel and the cost was more than I was willing to do.

Just stumbled upon a 4KW LPG Champion for $5-600. That I would consider. But wondering about the opinions whether it should be a thought. It even has an electric start option. Small and would go into the space I have.

Opinions or thoughts appreciated.
 
Feb 8, 2014
1,300
Columbia 36 Muskegon
If its an industrial or contractor model it will likely be very loud. Open frame, not enclosed like a Honda? Fire one of those up and you'll have the anchorage to yourself.
 
Last edited:
Dec 29, 2012
148
Hunter 37 Jacksonville
Specs state that it runs at 68 db. Normal conversation is 60. But appreciate the input.
 
Feb 8, 2014
1,300
Columbia 36 Muskegon
The Honda 2000 is 59dB. The progression is logarithmic, not linear. 68 is a LOT louder than 59. I'd want to hear one running under load (in person) before buying.
 
Dec 29, 2012
148
Hunter 37 Jacksonville
But the Honda that is the size I need(4 KW) is rated at 71. Though the rating on the Champion was at 21 feet...
 
May 24, 2004
7,179
CC 30 South Florida
Just beware about storing a gasoline generator in a locker or below deck. Gasoline fumes are heavier than air and, just like propane gas, can flow into low areas and pool into an explosive mix. Usually the caps in the fuel tank are vented to allow fuel flow but a safety cap that has a lever to close the vent when the unit is not in use is much safer as it reduces the escape of fumes. Even though Honda does not endorse the use of their generators for marine use there is a large history of use with satisfactory results and safety record. We have been using generators for a long time and at one point packed a Honda 3000 but it proved to be too heavy and bulky and did not stand to weather as the 2000. My take on the discount generators is that they lack in quality both in design and materials and this translates to a shorter useful life with less performance. Add to this an unproven safety track record in marine use and all of a sudden I'm glad I spent $1,000 on the little Honda 5 years ago. I have seen generators falling short of their advertised power output and understand that a generator is just as good as a smooth running and reliable engine. Another consideration might be the type of items that you intend to run; some generators are good for running lights and some electric tools but would not be recommended to operate electronics. I do admit that that with the limited power of the Honda we have to schedule the simultaneous use of appliances but it allows us to use any appliance aboard our boat, microwave oven, battery charger, Air conditioner (12.5K BTU), heater and all battery dependent appliance like refrigerator, lights and fans. We can run A/C and watch TV and run lights and the refrigerator and when we are done we'll reacharge the batteries. The offer of 4K watts even if the generator could produce them would do nothing for me, I rather value performance and reliability. You asked for opinions and comments and here they are.
 
Feb 6, 1998
11,711
Canadian Sailcraft 36T Casco Bay, ME
I've toyed with adding a generator. But always insisted that I would only accept a diesel and the cost was more than I was willing to do.
Just stumbled upon a 4KW LPG Small and would go into the space I have.
I don't know what you actually meant by that but PLEASE don't even consider installing this as a below deck unit like a diesel gen set. It is not intended for marine use, not ignition protected and not water cooled.. Marine generators for installation inside a vessel are well engineered and thought out and designed specifically for that purpose.. If you plan on running it above deck you could but good luck making any friends in the anchorage. Cheap generators specs on dB are often as full of bovine dung as the cow herself..
 
Dec 29, 2012
148
Hunter 37 Jacksonville
Oh man. You mean there really isn't a free lunch!!!

Thanks for the thoughts and information. Doesn't sound like a wise thought.

I know that I'm too lazy to drag one out on deck. Plus keeping it below somewhere. But then paying for that convenience would be the alternative.