Looking for a qualified yacht surveyor

Nov 29, 2013
10
Catalina 36 mkii Marion
Hi, I am looking for the name and contact info for a good qualified yacht surveyor for a boat that is sitting in ny. I would like him or her to be qualified to also test the engine. Can anyone provide info. Thanks for your help.
 

arf145

.
Nov 4, 2010
495
Beneteau 331 Deale, MD
Not a recommendation but an observation: I only see one in the NAMS listings near there:
Shawn G. Bartnett
Bartnett Marine Services, Inc.
52 Ontario Street, Honeoye Falls, New York, 14472, USA
Email: bartmarser@aol.com Telephone: 585.624.1380



Also, I think most surveyors do a general engine test, but not a specific engine wear test. Could be that the surveyor in the area might know of a qualified mechanic to do that.
 
Nov 24, 2012
586
Many of the surveyors do an oil test here. You can get a kit on line and get results back fairly quickly. Idea is to get a better idea of engine wear.
 
Feb 26, 2004
23,047
Catalina 34 224 Maple Bay, BC, Canada
Oil Tests

Many of the surveyors do an oil test here. You can get a kit on line and get results back fairly quickly. Idea is to get a better idea of engine wear.
The idea(s) are actually twofold:

1. A SINGLE test will tell you if there is any METAL in your oil, indicating something major is disintegrating inside the guts of your engine. Metal shavings in the oil? Hmm, not so good. Water shows up, too, but if your oil is milky, even YOU can figure that one out. :)

2. ONLY MULTIPLE oil samples over a period of time without oil changes can give you an idea of the TRENDS in the quality of your oil.

A single oil test just is not the be all-end all.

That's all.:eek:
 
Nov 24, 2012
586
The idea(s) are actually twofold: 1. A SINGLE test will tell you if there is any METAL in your oil, indicating something major is disintegrating inside the guts of your engine. Metal shavings in the oil? Hmm, not so good. Water shows up, too, but if your oil is milky, even YOU can figure that one out. :) 2. ONLY MULTIPLE oil samples over a period of time without oil changes can give you an idea of the TRENDS in the quality of your oil. A single oil test just is not the be all-end all. That's all.:eek:


From Boattest.com


"Analysis of lube and transmission oil is a dirt-cheap service that can pay you back many, many times over by discovering incipient problems before they become disasters. Most labs charge less than $25 for a standard oil analysis, which, includes a spectroscopic exam to determine the levels of metals, additives and possibly coolant in the oil; determines viscosity; and measures the percentage of solids in the oil. Other, specialized tests are available if necessary. And it's not just for diesel engines: Analyzing oil from gas engines and/or gearboxes is smart, too. "
 
Nov 29, 2013
10
Catalina 36 mkii Marion
Found a surveyor that does both

Hi, I found a good surveyor that does both. Name is Rob Scanlon. Contact number is 781-595-6225 and email is yacht1ship@aol.com. Does a good job, has a truck rigged out to perform surveys with 2,000 ft of hose to make sure he can get to water. Unfortunately he found problems with the boat so I am back to looking. The boat had serious delamination on the starboard forward quarter of the hull and also on the port side along with delamination of the rudder. So we never bothered to do the engine. Anyone looking at a first 35s5 on Long Island use caution.