It depends on where you are sailing. I think that if you want sneak across the sandbars into some secluded cove in Baie de Chaleurs, or head up the Miramachi River, you probably made the right choice.hi again.....when i bought my cherubnini27 last weekend it has a shoal keel....however i could have bought the same boat(1977)with a longer fin keel.did i make the right choice?