Thanks guys. I'm going to be the fourth owner of this boat, and I knew the last owner, and maintenance was not his strong suit. I'm assuming the butyl tape was used on most bedded hardware? 5200 is forever stuff. Actually have found the 4100 UV is a lot more forgiving and lasts as long.
All my chainplates, genoa cleats and dock cleats are bedded in butyl. Most of it original. I have not actually confirmed that my toe rails are, but all reports seem to indicate butyl, and there have been no issues to date.
Hatches and mast base were bedded in something else, 4200 or similar, and I’ve re-bedded them with 4200. I found my original winches were also bedded in 4200 or the like. My new winches and all other hardware are now bedded in butyl, which is my go to sealant for any condition were I can securely bolt down for compression.
Butyl is effective only with good compression. For things like hatches, with wood screws in old holes that may not provide sufficient compression, or a mast base with variable compression, I favor 4200.