Foxy's
Re Peter Roach's absolutely perfect itinerary, which I have done many times, I would add one extra bit. Foxy's is at Great Harbor on Jost Van Dyke, but Great Harbor is not exactly the most attractive anchorage. So grab a mooring at Little Harbor instead, which is just a short hop from Cane Garden Bay. Little Harbor has moorings, is small and quiet, and there's lobster at Sydney's Peace and Love. Then make Foxy's a REAL experience by doing The Death March. The road between Little Harbor and Great Harbor will give you some of the best exercise you've ever had, with beautiful ocean views over the cliff. By the time you reach Foxy's, a Heineken never tasted so good. Then take a taxi to White Bay. (Anchoring at White Bay is off limits with most charter companies.) It's a bit touristy but has a lovely, big beach--great unless a cruise ship is anchored out and the hoardes are ashore. But even watching those folks can be a lot of fun; "inappropriate Speedo spotting" can be very entertaining. A taxi all the way back to Little Harbor then becomes necessary (due to the Heinekens, Pain Killers, and tired kids).Another beautiful, and often deserted, anchorage (no moorings or bars) is Benures Bay on the north shore of Norman Island. It has fair snorkeling. A lucky pair of my Maui Jims now live on the bottom there.