I've got the same engine/raw water pump
When I open the raw water pump, to inspect or change the impeller, I always put on a new paper gasket. Carefully scrape off the old one, so as not to nick the soft metal of the pump housing. What I then do is drip a bit of biodegradable liquid detergent around the rim of the housing and then lay the new gasket in the that to keep it from moving while I replace the pump cover. You don't need a gasket sealer, IMHO.I also squirt a bit of the same liquid detergent around the blades of the impeller to lube it a bit before it starts sucking up water when I start the engine. Not sure it's needed, but it sure doesn't hurt.