Shawn,
The shelf seemed logical to me so that's where I put it. The refrigerant line set has to get from inside the box to the compressor outside and one single 2" hole in the ice box top was all I needed. I hadn't thought about this at the time but consider that the compressor produces heat too so the higher it's mounted the better as heat flows upward. Sub Zero refrigerators mount their machinery at the top of the appliance for this reason. The shelf also provides excellent access.
FastBreak,
$1K for the NovaKool picked up at the supplier (no shipping). The NovaKool was recommended over an Adler Barbour by a marine refrigeration professional for reasons I can't remember. I figured he knew more than me so why not? Both use the same Danfoss compressor. The NovaKool system had a variety of cold plate configurations available. I chose a 2 plate system that mounts 1/2" off the aft and inboard ice box walls on provided spacers, takes virtually no box space. Except for the power supply wire, the kit came complete, nothing else to supply.
Following the old rule of thumb regarding refrigeration, I added a battery with the installation. Will do the same when I install my windlass.