You have choices
Call Catalina, they will send you 2 ways to fix rudder slop. One is involved, pull the rudder out, full tube with epoxy. The other is simple and it's the one I used (per Catalina's instructions). I cut a couple of shims using vellum. One source of vellum is the clear plastic sheets you use on the copy machine to do overhead presentations. Cut a couple of shims, remove the tiller cap and insert. I shot some super lube in there once in a while. I did this "fix" about 5 years ago and it's kept things tight. Also if your steer cables are lose, you may want to tighten them, this also takes some slop out of the rubber. Like I said, call Catalina, they should fax you the instructions.