I can't comment on your longevity question (not having to deal with boating "seasons") but Micron Extra will work fine in fresh or brackish water. Micron 66 is formulated for saltwater only and will be ruined by prolonged exposure to anything else, as you now know.I'm thinking about using Micron Extra as I am in mostly in salt water but some of the rivers we go into are fresh. Our Micron 66 cornflaked after a couple of weeks on a mooring ball in brackish water.