G-man,
I liked what Smokey said. I had similar problems with my AP. I also replaced some rollers using screws. Another problem was my locking cam. I needed to change that also, because it failed.
I can tell you that the belts are a petroleum based material. The bad news is that sun, UV weather differences & salt effect them over time. This is what dries them & they shrink & become hardened. I've had my AP since 1992 with only the one fix mentioned above. It's 22 years old but still going strong. I believe using a binnacle cover had a lot to do with this. I had a nylon(?) inside covering I believe cuts down on UV and moisture.
Problem with plastic rollers & locking cam is that as the belt shrinks, more pressure is applied causing them to wear. The first sign it's time to change the belt is when releasing the lock, I can hear the belt teeth "slipping sound," like it' not fully released.
Another thing to look for is if engaged, you find the lock lever lifting up on it's own.
I waited too long the first time. Had I changed out the belt early on, I probably would not have worn out the parts. I always order two belts. I keep the spare stashed in a low compartment in a black trash bag. UV (the monster) goes right thru fiberglass. I had a spare belt onboard on one of my shelves, for two years. When I went to use it, it was as bad as the belt I was changing out.
CR