When you say the pump made noise and moved water around, but it took 45 mins with a sponge to dry the bilge; it's a bit confusing. Was there any water discharging overboard? Is the pump inlet clogged with debris? Is the discharge hose connected to the pump, or is it discharging back into the bilge?
I put a Rule 1100 automatic in my Mac 26M. It moves a good bit of water, which is what I wanted.
Read
@Benny17441 's post carefully regarding pump capacity ratings. Very good info.
After you have installed or repaired your pumps, test them at least twice to verify you don't have a trap/airlock in your discharge hose.