Right: check the magnetic
First eliminate the possibility that your magnetic compass is off. This can happen not just if an iron object is placed next to the fluxgate compass unit (which is under the aft bunk access ports, and mounted on the aft bulkhead in your 356), but can also happen if any magnetic material is placed anywhere within about 6 feet from the steering pedestal. This includes smaller items that can become magnetized, such as non-aluminum beer or soft drink cans, screwdrivers, containers, or any other items that contain iron.
Once you have determined that that is not the case then sail the boat in a known magnetic direction aiming for a fixed landmark according to an official chart, and see what the compass reads. Repeat for each of the cardinal directions. If your magnetic compass still reads more than a few degrees off the true magnetic direction you have to "swing" the compass and adjust is two compensation magnets (with a brass screwdriver), but it would be a clear indicator that your autopilot compass is not the culprit.
Only after this is done should you attempt to correct your autopilot compass.
Good luck.