Any feedback/opinions on a dripless shaft seal TidesMarine vs PYI PSS?

[ArkadiyS]

I am looking to replace my shaft seal, and wanted to know if there are preferences between TidesMarine versus PYI PSS seals. They seem to be similar in pricing, but different approaches. Thanks!

 

[sail sfbay]

My experience is limited to PYI PSS, which was recommended by my boatyard, on a powerboat with two new large diameter. Hopefully some enginers and boat mechanics will weigh in. In the meantime. these articles expains the differences between PYI and TidesMarine PSS seals: Troubleshooter: Understanding Shaft Seals - PassageMaker AND Tides Marine Shaft Seals - What To Know About Tides Dripless Shaft Seals (citimarinestore.com).

These threads may address your question Shaft Seal - PSS or Tides Marine Lip Seal ? - Cruisers & Sailing Forums (cruisersforum.com), Tides Marine - Shaft Seals? | Downeast Boat Forum AND Shaft Seals - Cruising Anarchy - Sailing Anarchy Forums.

 

[senang]

My opinion is to look at Volvo shaft seals. Very simple, nearly maintenance free, long life. I am a happy user.