Battery Switch
It would help to describe the batteries. A deep cycle battery is designed to support starting. The standard wiring would be 1. The "house" battery is usually 2.The switch probably has 4 positions - 1, 2, Both, and Off. The idea is to set it to 1 to start the engine. Once started, set it to "Both" to charge both batteries. When on the hook, or otherwise using power for lights, instruments, and radio, set the switch to 2 to avoid running down your starter battery.With a boat as old as ours, you should check _all_ the wiring, both to ensure things are really wired as you expect, and for any problems with insulation, connection corrosion, and simply wrong connections. No telling what has happened over 20+ years!By the way, Lady Lillie is wired for two batteries, but only has one. Because our "house" load is so small, we can run cabin lights overnight and still have plenty of reserve to start in the morning. We like the simplicity, and we do have sails as a reserve power source!DavidLady Lillie