Erik,
Don't give up on the hydraulics, it's a really good solution and robustly built, but you do need to take care of it. Sailtec has procedures....First, the strut should be stored vertical during the off season. second, you may have to purge air bubbles-with the valve open, hold the strut upright and pump the piston fully up, then down, and repeat-maybe 5-6 times. If that doesn't work, you may want to flush and replace the hydraulic oil. My 2006 wasn't cared for-when I flushed the strut, I got out about 1/4 cup of greenish cloudy stuff. it should hold 250ml (about a cup) of clear amber fluid. Once replaced, the strut worked fine.