One of our favorites is Deshaies, Guadeloupe, FWI. Not for any other reason than across the street from the dinghy dock is the best French Bakery anywhere in the Antilles.
If you have to be in St Thomas, then Honeymoon is about as good as it gets, though it can be a bit crowded and noisy on the week ends and during the Puerto Rican vacations.
We love Port Elizabeth in Admiralty Bay Bequia. Some of the nicest fruit and vegetables available anywhere in the Windwards or Leewards, right across the street from the dinghy dock, but the internet there is atrocious. Overall, the best prices by far on medications anywhere in the islands.
For just sheer beauty, it's a toss up between Sandy Island off Hillsborough and Saltwhistle, but Sandy Island marine park is expensive and Saltwhistle is a madhouse all the time.
But overall, I'd have to say our favorite anchorage between Puerto Rico and Trinidad is White Island, off Carriacou. Though it is the rare day when one can visit, if conditions allow, one should make every effort to visit this off the beaten path anchorage.
End of travel log, sorry.