Just replaced my permeated sanitation hose over the winter on a 2009 H36 I bought last season, and completely did away with the also permeated macerator system and closed and capped the thru hull. Hunter didn't install a vented loop for the macerator either in my case, and in fact straight plumbed from the bottom of the holding tank to the macerator and from there to the thru hull. The macerator sat on the bottom of the stern locker, just like the holding tank. Not shocking it permeated. I sail in the Chesapeake bay, so will never use a macerator. I also found the macerator thru hull frozen OPEN when I bought the boat (which I fixed at haulout after reasonable tapping on the handle didn't work). However, I never had any backflow into my holding tank. Its interesting you do. Oh, and I took Peggy's advice and used the Raritan Saniflex, and it was every bit as easy to use as she says. Absolutely did not mind paying a little more for much better (and easier to install) sanitation hose!! Wrong place to skimp, in case anyone is thinking that way.