So, let's rank the sailing movies.
1. Master & Commander
2. White Squall
3. Mutiny on Bounty (Mel Gibson)
4 Dead Calm
4 Wind
5 All is Lost
If you remember in the very first scene of White Squall, as they were coming to the boat in the car one crew member said that another crew member was, "asleep in the sheet" (forward?). That ruined the whole movie for me. If the producers don't know the difference between a sheet and a sail, they probably shouldn't be making a movie about sailing!
There were some excellent sailing movies in the Hornblower series and the "Honor" series from the books by Macomber. I preferred Mutiny on the Bounty with Charles Laughton and Clark Gable to the Mel Gibson version. Men against the Sea was also a good movie about after Bligh left the Bounty.
Dead Calm was indeed a great movie, with Stormvogel as the star. My heart just ached when the spear went into the door, ouch! I saw her a few years back in Antigua and someone with not quite enough money was trying to bring her back to her former glory.
Don't forget Wake of the Red Witch and The Sea Wolf.