Feelin' foolish at Barnegat Light

Oct 26, 2008
6,277
Catalina 320 Barnegat, NJ
Sue & I took Friday afternoon off to get down to the boat and anchor out for the night. Knowing that a tropical storm was on the way, I figured Friday into Saturday was a small window to make something out of the weekend (boatwise). First, our dock neighbor came by and said "you really going out in this?" Gee thanks! That set Sue on edge right off the bat. She knew about the storm but was trusting me when I said we had time. The wind was light on Friday afternoon. Predictions indicated it would be picking up overnight to 20 knots from the NE on Saturday morning. But the predictions also indicated that it wouldn't change much until the system would arrive possibly Sunday. It would take only about an hour and half both ways to Barnegat Light and back, so we weren't getting too far away. We made plans to meet up with Sue's best friend for dinner and a visit to the light house, so I was really looking forward to my first trip through the Oyster Creek Channel to the anchorage at Barnegat Light.
Not to bore you with too many details, we had a pleasant trip through the channel, found a place to tie up for the evening, had a wonderful dinner with lots of laughs, visited the light house, and then anchored for the night.

I had a little difficulty setting the anchor in a good spot as it was getting dark but we finally got a good hold next to a few other boats (who were tied to moorings). We slept fine until 2:30 when the wind dialed up to about 17 knots. Sue was anxious and I have to admit that I was nervous down below as the boat was sailing on the anchor. Eventually, I curled up in the cockpit with a cushion and a blanket, feeling comfortable on anchor watch because I could see we weren't going anywhere. But I knew that Sue was counting down the minutes until sunrise.

When it finally got light and the sun broke the horizon at 6:30, we had the engine running and broke the anchor free. The whole anchorage is surrounded by very shallow water and it was blowing at 20 knots by this time, with higher gusts. I wasn't nervous about the conditions so much as I was nervous about Sue's growing state of anxiety. But it really helped that it was light out and we were on our way home. Unfortunately, this is my first time up this channel to the inlet and finding the way back was not so familiar. (My handheld GPS was lost in our move, so I'm without GPS and relying on my paper chart and day markers.) With a little difficulty, we located the proper day markers to lead us back to Barnegat Bay.

We continued on and soon entered the Double Creek Channel and followed that out. The only problem was that I was supposed to be in the Oyster Creek Channel! My chart doesn't show Double Creek coming into the anchorage; instead it shows Double Creek terminating on the other side of the dyke. Besides, I had heard that the Double Creek Channel markers had been removed because it had shoaled too much for navigation. Well, my first gut feeling that we were in the wrong location was the appearance of the sedge islands that didn't look familiar to the way we entered. But my head told me that I was following the only possible way out and I didn't see any other channel markers.

We were following the channel in comfortable depths and it was still about 12' deep when I saw the last pair of daymarks, accompanied by a group of white markers that looked ominous. We had the wind at our back and the current was with us, so we were really moving along. I had Sue get the binocs out and said "what do they say??". She couldn't read them with the motion as we rapidly approached. But finally, we were close enough to read "Danger" without needing the binocs. Sue exploded with " they say DANGER! ... where are we?!?! ..... how do you NOT know where we are?!?!?" It was actually pretty comical but I wasn't laughing, then!

Luckily, I was able to turn around inside the channel and double back without any additional trouble. When we found our way back to Oyster Creek Channel, I noted that there was not any Preferred Channel daymarker (at least none that I saw). I was still pretty sheepish as we found our way back to Barnegat Bay ... and feeling sheepish, still.
 
Jul 14, 2015
840
Catalina 30 Stillhouse Hollow Marina
She is a braver admiral than I have. Glad you made it safely.
 

capta

.
Jun 4, 2009
4,935
Pearson 530 Admiralty Bay, Bequia SVG
All's well that ends well.
Good on you both for DOING! That guy on the dock didn't have "a pleasant trip through the channel, found a place to tie up for the evening, had a wonderful dinner with lots of laughs, visited the light house, and then anchored for the night".
My only suggestion is that you upgrade your #1 anchor and tackle so that you both CAN sleep, no matter what the wind is. Well, up to 50 or 60 knots, anyway.
 
  • Like
Likes: LuzSD
Oct 26, 2008
6,277
Catalina 320 Barnegat, NJ
Yes, capta, I think I need to upgrade my anchor for more serious anchoring adventures. My Danforth with 15' of chain is essentially a lunch hook, although it does pretty well in the clay-like mud we have here. It was a fair amount of work to break it out of the mud on Saturday morning, so I feel pretty good about that. My dock neighbor has been sailing in this area for a long time and has a lot of experience with the weather changes here. I take his advise seriously. If he REALLY thought we shouldn't go out, he probably would have said so.
 
  • Like
Likes: capta
Nov 9, 2008
1,338
Pearson-O'Day 290 Portland Maine
Scott,
I feel for you. Haven't been in the exact position but have had a few situations. You might consider packing you tablet or cellphone with Navionics for backup. Its free and accurate.
 

Bob S

.
Sep 27, 2007
1,804
Beneteau 393 New Bedford, MA
Where would we be without our admirals! Good story. One we can all relate to. Glad you made it back OK
 
May 17, 2004
5,679
Beneteau Oceanis 37 Havre de Grace
Sounds like you learned some lessons, and all's well that ends well. From what I remember of Barnegat Bay, un-forecasted increases to 17 kts at 2:30 am are not uncommon, even in the absence of tropical systems. Not to start any kind of anchor debate, the one downside of the danforth in Baenegat is that it doesn't set well in patches of seaweed, which may have been your troubles when you first tried to anchor. I agree with Capta that you'll sleep much better with an anchor that you have total confidence in.
 
May 27, 2004
2,054
Hunter 30_74-83 Ponce Inlet FL
We should all remember to "Turn Around" if you're not sure of your position.
And so you did!
 

Gunni

.
Mar 16, 2010
5,937
Beneteau 411 Oceanis Annapolis
One of the characteristics of a cyclonic storm is the way the wind shifts radically. That happened again during this storm when Hermine crossed the Outer Banks of NC. The storm had strong easterlies and little damage until it passed the the winds filled in from the NNW and pushed the sound water ashore causing flooding.

Radical wind shifts and wide ranging depths are big challenges for your ground tackle.
 

jssailem

SBO Weather and Forecasting Forum Jim & John
Oct 22, 2014
23,143
CAL 35 Cruiser #21 moored EVERETT WA
Great story Scott. As Grizzard said, "You Turned Around". When in doubt stop what you are doing and think it out. You said your GPS failed. Do you have a regular compass on board? From looking at the chart of the area to divert down the Double Creek Channel takes you on a heading of 270M and eventually towards 180M. The Oyster Creek Channel is north of 270M and well out into the Bay before you start to change heading. (area chart http://nj.usharbors.com/explore/harbor-guide/barnegat-inlet-uscg-station ) I always get an awareness of a new area in my head by use of such charts and then fit the images I see to that chart image. Sounds like you felt something was wrong as you turned.
Glad you recovered smartly and made the return trip uneventful. Now you have done it you will be more sea wise and may become the guy on the dock helping the next newbie with knowledge about your area.
Fair winds.
 
Oct 26, 2008
6,277
Catalina 320 Barnegat, NJ
Thanks for that reference js. The chart doesn't represent that there is actually a dredged and marked channel from Oyster Creek to Double Creek right in that area where "shoaling" is indicated (upside down writing). That is what threw me. The Oyster Creek Channel makes a little jog to the right just beyond that point, about where the depth is marked between "8" and "14". I don't know how I missed those marks at first, but possibly because the markers for Double Creek were clearly in view (they are smaller, and newer looking (plastic?) markers, not the old steel cans and nuns that mark Oyster Creek). The other thing that threw me is that dock neighbors have been telling me that it used to be possible to take Double Creek from Barnegat Bay to the backside of the Dike (before the channel eventually shoaled-up on the BB side), but it wasn't possible to go around the Dike to get to Oyster Creek and Barnegat Light. Well, I think I discovered otherwise. I actually may have preferred to anchor on the backside for better protection, but I wouldn't have tried to navigate there in the dark anyway. We anchored tucked in against the Dike near the marker with red light on the chart.

We turned around at the end of the channel where the chart depth indicates "7". I actually think that we could have passed through without grounding with our 3'8" draft. A runabout was working his way toward the inlet on this route as we were turning around. We were close to high tide. But the tidal range at this location is very small, less than 2', I believe. I didn't want to take a chance during weather that was expected to turn nasty. On a nice day, I might see if it is possible to get through. It's only sand (as far as I know).

I don't even think to use my compass. Everything is pretty much in view anyway. I should have known right off that I was in the wrong location just because the buildings near our marina were clearly in view right in front of us! :doh:
 
Last edited:
Feb 21, 2008
413
Hunter 33 Metedeconk River
Glad everything worked out well also. My first trip thru Barnegat Inlet was bringing my new to me boat, home for the first time from just south of Atlantic City. We were planning on going up to Manasquan Inlet rather than coming thru Barnegat Inlet but the hour was getting late, we were behind schedule so we decided to go in BI and save about an hour and a half. The admiral was nervous, as she always is, and there was a BoatUS tow boat at the entrance. I radioed BoatUS and he nicely escorted us thru the ever changing twist and turns. Even though we followed directly behind him, and I was watching my depth, we still lightly grounded in the Oyster Creek Channel. He gave us a hand, apologized and we went our way. Barnegat Inlet a tough trip. I'd say you did just fine.
 

LuzSD

.
Feb 21, 2009
1,009
Catalina 30 San Diego/ Dana Point, Ca.
Awesome story Scott .. I'm so impressed with you both! Art and I have had our best lessons from those days that we wonder if we'll make the evening news! But your adventure was brave and successful! Well done you two!
 
Jul 12, 2011
1,165
Leopard 40 Jupiter, Florida
Thanks for the story, Scott. We've all been there, trying to match the little marks on the chart to the view of daymarks and trees while coastal navigating. Seems like you did everything right, and have an adventure to tell about -- which is much better than saying you spent Saturday cleaning out the garage! Plus-one to Capta's suggestion to increasing your anchor capabilities. That thing is more than a convenience, it's the last line of defense if everything else fails and you're being pushed onto the rocks. Keep on adventuring!
 
Jun 19, 2004
365
Island Packet IP 32 99 Forked River, NJ
Being based in Ocean Gate we've made many transits thru the Barnegat inlet. Our experience is to pay attention to the buoys more than charts since the channel changes often.
Friend of ours ran aground 3 times last week in the double creek channel on his small powerboat with 2 ft draft.
 
Oct 26, 2008
6,277
Catalina 320 Barnegat, NJ
Just like Slocum. Where next?

All U Get
Exactly! ;) Circumnavigate Long Beach Island, I think. About 60 miles ... about a third of it in the Atlantic. I'm assuming there is navigable channel from Beach Haven to Barnegat. I'd also like some advise regarding Little Egg Inlet. I seem to get conflicting reports (whether it is more or less tricky than Barnegat Inlet).
 
Oct 26, 2008
6,277
Catalina 320 Barnegat, NJ
Being based in Ocean Gate we've made many transits thru the Barnegat inlet. Our experience is to pay attention to the buoys more than charts since the channel changes often.
Friend of ours ran aground 3 times last week in the double creek channel on his small powerboat with 2 ft draft.
Jim, what is your experience with regard to the inlet itself? I think I'd like my next trip to actually get outside to the Atlantic. Do you find it trickier in the inlet or the channel?

Our marina is in Double Creek, but on the west side of the bay. A navigable channel from the bay to Barnegat Light would be a big shortcut for us. I assume that your friends groundings were on the bay side, where it shoals at the entrance leading toward the dike.
 

jssailem

SBO Weather and Forecasting Forum Jim & John
Oct 22, 2014
23,143
CAL 35 Cruiser #21 moored EVERETT WA
I don't even think to use my compass
Really. I always give it a check, even when I'm following my GPS. Guess old habits die hard.
I was looking at the charts of your area. Wow, you have some shallow water and a few wrecks to navigate around. Wrong tide and your 5ft draft, you likely would not have made it to the Double Creek Channel from the lighthouse anchorage. I suspect the winter storms move the shoals about increasing the challenge. Only way to know your limits is to intelligently test them. This requires caution, and a good charting of what you learned, so you only repeat the good stuff.

upload_2016-9-8_10-8-15.png
 
Jun 19, 2004
365
Island Packet IP 32 99 Forked River, NJ
OK Scott... the biggest problem I've ever had at the inlet has been with other boaters. I've heard stories about LBI so I've never considered it. I always time our trips to take advantage of the tides trying to get at the lighthouse at about slack tide. If you like send me a PM.