I've seen worse. Way worse.
Looking at the previous holes it is obvious those deck penetrations were never potted so when the bolts let water through it went directly into that wood.
Make sure your compression post is installed and at the correct height.
If that was mine I would let that dry out completely.
Lay a layer of thickened resin over the entire area to fill the holes and all gaps.
Immediately lay 2 layers of Biaxial cloth over it.
Slap a piece of 1/4 Inch ply with edges cut at over that that fits closely to the edges.
Another layer of thickened resin followed either by your old cut out top or -
6-7 Layers of new bi-ax cloth. I usually top with a layer of CSM that is essentially sacrificial
because I would be sanding a lot of that off while smoothing and shaping.
The main issue you might have is that you cut pretty close to the edges where the "humps" are on the sides and rear.
If you want your new top to have strength it needs to be well overlapped to the existing fiberglass to spread the load.
In the front it will be easy - where the humps are not so much. Lots of hand sanding in your future on those places.
Once your new top is in and shaped and smoothed - redrill the holes for the bolts and POT THEM.
Paint.
Counter sink your holes and reinstall your mast step, I use butyl tape from Maine Sail.
Put up your mast and make adjustments as needed because your height may have changed slightly.
After I put my new top on I had to remove 1/2" from the bottom of my compression post to make everything right.
It will be a learning experience for you, its not hard, just can be tedious with all of the steps.
Especially sanding along those humps.
This is just off the top of my head, there are many approaches to this - I'm not saying mine is right, just a method.
Looking at the previous holes it is obvious those deck penetrations were never potted so when the bolts let water through it went directly into that wood.
Make sure your compression post is installed and at the correct height.
If that was mine I would let that dry out completely.
Lay a layer of thickened resin over the entire area to fill the holes and all gaps.
Immediately lay 2 layers of Biaxial cloth over it.
Slap a piece of 1/4 Inch ply with edges cut at over that that fits closely to the edges.
Another layer of thickened resin followed either by your old cut out top or -
6-7 Layers of new bi-ax cloth. I usually top with a layer of CSM that is essentially sacrificial
because I would be sanding a lot of that off while smoothing and shaping.
The main issue you might have is that you cut pretty close to the edges where the "humps" are on the sides and rear.
If you want your new top to have strength it needs to be well overlapped to the existing fiberglass to spread the load.
In the front it will be easy - where the humps are not so much. Lots of hand sanding in your future on those places.
Once your new top is in and shaped and smoothed - redrill the holes for the bolts and POT THEM.
Paint.
Counter sink your holes and reinstall your mast step, I use butyl tape from Maine Sail.
Put up your mast and make adjustments as needed because your height may have changed slightly.
After I put my new top on I had to remove 1/2" from the bottom of my compression post to make everything right.
It will be a learning experience for you, its not hard, just can be tedious with all of the steps.
Especially sanding along those humps.
This is just off the top of my head, there are many approaches to this - I'm not saying mine is right, just a method.