I often think this is what I'd prefer. But I do feel that a pilothouse is likely to be a bit more convenient in the winter. No setting up or taking down, it's always just there when you need it. Also, in the Pacific northwest it seems like you spend a lot of time motoring in certain areas and at certain times of year, either because of rain, currents, lack of wind, or a combination. I imagine a pilothouse is a little nicer for two people when you have a long day inside.why not a good enclosure on a 'regular' boat