I have a new to me 1986 mac 25. The companionway hatch has a lot of play from side to side. It squeaks like crazy and is hard to open. Its a mess. I'm thinking of getting rid of the wood and making my own with HD PE or UHMW or Starboard. I've seen and heard of these materials, but I know very little about them. I love the idea of low maintenance ad maybe it will function better too. Can someone help me pick out the right material for the job. The color white is ok with me.